1. The Yanomamo
people do not have courts or laws or juries of their peers. In western society
most of the time a person will be punished for killing another person. Also
revenge killings are punished, not as severely, given the circumstances, but
punished. A judge is the deciding factor on how a killing will be punished. The
Yanomamo have a headman who decides if a revenge killing will take place. Most
of the killings take place over sexual issues, coercing woman, taking women, infidelity
or jealousy. In our society these issues do not usually warrant killing,
however passion killings are not punished as severely as other killings.
2. The Yanomamo
people engage in progressive fighting. Shouting matches, chest pounding duels,
side slapping, club fightings, fighting with machetes, and finally bows and
arrows. If dueling occurs within the villages, village fission takes place and
then both parties begin raiding each other.
3. There are
many benefits for Unokais the first benefits is the Unokais have more marriage
partners, Ferociousness is considered a benefit for family and the marriage
partners. All headmen are Unokais. So raiding can increase a man’s social
status. Unokais have more children because of the availability of marriage
partners. And finally if retaliation is
swift it can act as a deterrent and keep the mortality rate low. A man who is a
non-unokais may survive to live another day, However he is often ridiculed and
his women are prey to sexual advances and seduction.
4. The
headman or Pata is always a Unokais.
Political status- Since the decision to raid is up to the headman he
carries status and some political control.
Social Status- the Yanomamo organizes their villages around patrilineal
kinship groups. Unokais is a gives a person social status. Non Unokais are
ridiculed and lose their women. Being strong and fierce is looked upon as
providing safety for the village. Economic
support- The headman is treated with respect and usually in tribal
societies the people will give him extra food or possessions in accordance with
his status. Also, the wives do work and provide, so if he has more wives, more
work will be completed for him. Kinship- The kinship is patrilineal and
if there are two descent lines often the people will marry within the descent
lines. This gives the headman many close kin. Which in turn will raid with him
and make his village strong and the mortality rate lessen, because of the swift
retribution and the reputation of being fierce? Marriage- A Unokais has more marriage partners, either by coercing
or seduction or attractiveness. The larger the descent group the more
protection for his kin and the more attractive he will be for marriage. The Unokais
will have more children than non-unokais.
The revenge killings influence the all the areas of, social status,
political status economic support kinship bonds. It is believed the revenge
killings occur for competition for women and food, thus insuring the survival
of someone’s genetics or inclusive fitness.
5. We need
laws to prevent killings because our society is a huge multi-cultured society.
One culture may have different standards than another culture and the group cannot
control the behavior of so many different value systems. When a situation
arises where the needs of a group is based on limited resources, such as food or
land, conflict will arise if the benefits of the conflict outweigh the costs.
It is a biological imperative to reproduce and insure our genetics will be
carried forward. Conflict for sexual rights and privileges takes place in many
cultures and is based on the theory of inclusive fitness.
Your answer for number 5 was really interesting and something I didn't think about when answering the question. You pointed out that we live in a multi-cultured society with lots of different value systems. I do remember reading this in the tutorial for this week but it didn't cross my mind when I was writing my blog.
ReplyDeleteA commonality in most of these posts is that the Yanomamo do not have laws regarding killings, which I find curious. So they can kill without restrictions, any time they want, and whomever they want? Just because their laws don't resemble our own doesn't mean they don't exist.
ReplyDeleteIn your description of the revenge killing system, why do these killings occur? Can you describe the cyclic nature?
Great comparison between unokais and non-unokais. Good explanation of the impact of this system on other aspects of their culture.
Great final paragraph. Excellent job pulling in the biological nature of violent behaviors. We have social laws to prevent us from acting on biological, instinctual behaviors which benefited our ancestors in the past.