Body Rituals for the Nacirema
The Nacirema people are a people that practice complex
rituals concerning their bodies. This
culture has many levels of medicine men to assist in the body rituals. The
medicine men all require gifts for their participation in these rituals. The ceremonies
are done in special rooms, in secret, by the people.
This culture is very narcissistic, The article states ‘’
that a considerable portion of the day is spent in ritual activities and the
focus of these activities are their bodies,” The article explains that the
Nacirema have special rooms where these rituals are done in secret. Charms boxes, and special substances from the
medicine men are included in the ceremonies. The purpose of all these rituals
and ceremonies is to secure or prevent loss of friendship and love. Many activities are needed to help a culture
survive and since such an inordinate amount of time and gift-giving are
involved with the body rituals , I would conclude that the individuals in
this culture are narcissistic.
The Nacirema appear to be chauvinistic towards women. The females that are involved with the Latipso
ceremonies are poked and prodded and manipulated. Since the ideal body image for the females
are impossible to achieve with a normal female, the females have to have
ceremonies performed on their breasts to achieve the ideal size and shape. When the female achieves the correct breast
size, she is put on display and given gifts. Mothers are often accused of
bewitching their children while involved in teaching them the body
rituals. The article states that
medicine men are involved with the rituals except in the Latipso ceremony,
where the female’s position is to serve.
I would conclude that the female roles are subservient to the male roles
in this culture.
This cultural displays painful and brutal behavior while
practicing their rituals and ceremonies. The example given in the article
discusses the holy mouth man. This
person pokes awls into nerves and makes holes in people’s mouths. Large
portions of the teeth are gouged out to make room for the magical material that
is placed in the holes. The people who
participate in the purification ceremonies for the sick are stripped naked and
rolled around on a hard bed. These
examples show that the people are willing to go through pain and humiliation to
be purified with the medicine man’s participation. The people are brutal in their rituals.
The article describes the Nacirema spends much of their time
devoted to economic pursuit. I would
describe the Nacirema people as superficial. It appears that most of their
labor and time is spent on rituals to help them achieve love and
friendship. The labor is used to be able
to gift give the medicine man to improve their bodies and mouths. Although this may have some benefit to their culture,
it does not seem to be a substantial contribution to a culture. I believe this
culture is very superficial.
I would describe this culture as being obsessive. The
examples given in the article show a culture with special shrines for secret
rituals and ceremonies. These ceremonies are done alone. Many of the ceremonies involve large gifts
exchanged. The more wealthy people have
many shrine rooms. The women bake their heads. The article describes an array
of rituals from inserting the hog hairs in the mouth, to the daily ablution
with the special water. All of these rituals are performed for the purpose to
prevent sickness and decay in the body.
The article states that the Nacirema have a fear of loss of love and friendship
due to the state of their mouths and bodies.
This is a clear example of a people who value their selves above the
people surrounding them. So I conclude
that the Nacierma are self-obsessed with their needs.
Part B
1. I feel my
descriptive words were very harsh. I
feel ashamed that anyone would use these words to describe my culture. I am not sure the words were inaccurate. I learned that looking at a certain set of
actions is simplistic. There are many
people in our culture, who work hard, helping the other people. Many people do
not spend hours with make-up or worry about their body images. The overall
lesson I learned is that studying one segment of a culture will not give you
the whole story. The understanding of a culture
could take years.
2. All of my
descriptive words contain bias. My
underlying bias comes from my cultural background, valuing the work ethic and
productivity. My assumption is that, pursuing
a perfect body image is of no value. In
the context of our culture, body image plays an important role. My bias has allowed me to judge the Nacirema
as self-absorbed.
3 The first word I would change would be narcisstic. I would change the word to tenacious. The statement would say: (The Nacirema is
very tenacious in practicing their rituals.) I stated that the Nacirema are chauvinistic. I would amend chauvinistic to a less biased
word. The statement would read, (that
females have specific roles determined by their gender, which entails them
displaying their breasts.) I stated that
the Nacirema are brutal. I would change
brutal to a less loaded word. (The
Nacierma are of a strong disposition in enduring the many painful rituals in
their belief system.) I used the word
superficial. This bias could be
rephrased as: (In the Nacierema culture the value of love and friendship is so
strong that the Nacierma’s daily routines are occupied in upholding these
values.) The last descriptive word I
used was, obsessive. I would change that
word to persistent. (This culture is persistent
in following their beliefs through the ceremonies and rituals performed.)
4. It is important to
minimize bias in judging other cultures, because the bias can warp or change
the view of the culture. I think it is
impossible to avoid personal bias in learning of other cultures. We cannot eradicate bias from our worldview, we
carry are values learned from our culture, so How can we get away from
ourselves?. Any bias at all can alter and change a persons's
entire view of a culture and or society.
Yes, I believe that your words are bias, but not harsh to other people they might be. Reading your story made me understand where your coming from. I like how you took the words you used and chained them to be better. great work on that. There will be judging no matter where we are or what culture we are in, even if we don't me it, or even if we don't know what we are saying is bad and I feel its the way of life. Do you think that there will be judgment everywhere we going in life?
ReplyDeleteYou say: "I feel my descriptive words were very harsh."
ReplyDeleteYes! :-) That doesn't mean they weren't accurate from your perspective (and it's not something I would feel shame over), but from an anthropological perspective, there was too much judgement and bias in there. Good for you for acknowledging it and I liked your exploration in section 3 about how to change your word choice for a less biased perspective.
Good final section and great post!
One of your words that did stand out for me is superficial. And I agree with you. In my opinion this word is not a bias, it is just a descriptive word. So you should not feel harsh about your point of view or how you described them. In addition, as the teacher said it is your perspective. We all come from different cultures and have different perspective about what others do.
ReplyDeleteI may not have found your words "harsh" but "honestly" responsive to how you felt/reacted to a cultural practice. We pull from what we have been exposed to. I found it enlightening your reactions to a culture so very different from ours. Rebecca, your responses to your choice of words showed how you thought through these responses and reached out to learn/recognize more about yourself. Good job I hope I can grow with expanding my perspectives!
ReplyDelete